“Too Descriptive”: Summary vs Synthesis in Your Thesis Literature Review

You have just come out of a meeting with your supervisor. The feedback on your literature review was short: “Too descriptive.” Or perhaps: “This reads like a summary.” The first diagnosis that comes to mind is that you haven’t read enough. So you go back to the articles and add more to the chapter. At the next meeting, the comment is the same.
Sometimes you do need to read more. But until you work out what the studies say together, new reading simply piles up in the same place. “Too descriptive” is instructive here, because your supervisor usually means something else: the studies sit side by side, and no relationships have been drawn between them. In short, there is a summary but no synthesis.
I hold a PhD from the University of Michigan. I have taught research methods from undergraduate to doctoral level, supervised master’s and PhD theses, and coached many students one-to-one on their theses. I have seen this loop many times. In this post, I will show the difference using a single example.
Summary vs synthesis
To show the difference, let’s take three studies on remote work and productivity. They are entirely fictional; I’ll call them A, B and C.
First, a paragraph of the kind you often find in a literature review — a summary:
A, in a survey of 1,200 white-collar employees, found that productivity rose as the frequency of remote work increased. B observed a similar relationship in a panel study that measured 600 employees twice, one year apart. C, however, observed this relationship only among employees with a separate workspace at home.
Nothing in this paragraph is wrong. Every sentence is accurate, and every finding is reported correctly. But each sentence stands on its own, and the work of connecting the findings is left to the reader.

Now a paragraph built from the same three findings, this time as a synthesis:
A positive association between remote-work frequency and productivity has been observed both in a cross-sectional survey and in a panel study that followed the same employees over time (A; B). C, however, finds that the association holds under one condition only: among employees with a separate workspace at home. Because A and B did not distinguish employees by their home conditions, these two studies cannot tell us how far the association they found depends on that condition.
No new study has been added; the findings are the same. Two things have changed:
The subjects of the sentences. In the first paragraph, the studies were doing the talking (“A … found”). In the second, the relationship between remote work and productivity is. The studies sit in parentheses, as the evidence behind the claim.
The last sentence. Connecting the three studies brings out something none of them says on its own: a place the studies we read did not look.

Look at your own chapter
Open a page of your chapter and look only at the subjects of your sentences. If most of them begin with an author’s name (“X (2020) found …”, “According to Y …”), what you have is most likely a summary. Many literature reviews start out this way in the first draft; and if left there, they read as descriptive.
A citation that opens with the author’s name is not a mistake in itself. It is the right choice when you are discussing a particular study — its design or its sample, say. The problem is a chapter that runs in this pattern from start to finish.
This check shows you the problem; it does not solve it. Moving author names into parentheses at the end of the sentence does not turn a summary into a synthesis. Nor does adding sources; that only makes the summary longer. Why? Because synthesis means putting the studies in conversation with each other: Where do they agree? Does any of them tie the finding to a particular condition? Where do they contradict each other?

Where the studies fall silent: gaps in the literature
The conversation also has its silences. The last sentence of our example pointed to one: two of the studies we read did not look at home conditions.
When you put the studies in conversation, gaps in the literature become visible in these silences. And there is usually more than one.
One distinction matters here: gaps in the literature are found by reading; your angle chooses the research gap. The research gap your thesis will be built on is one of these silences. Which one it will be depends on the angle from which you approach the puzzle (the problem) behind your study.

The literature review is an argument
A literature review does not report what you have read, one study after another. It is an argument that moves towards a destination, and that destination is the research gap. This is why the chapter can be written as an argument only once the studies have been put in conversation and the research gap has emerged. Until then, what you write — reading notes, draft paragraphs — is raw material.
Working on your own chapter
In this post I showed the difference on a single example. Putting the studies in your chapter in conversation — working out where they agree, where one ties a finding to a condition, where they contradict each other and where they fall silent — is the work we do together in one-to-one coaching.
